Burn-up credit criticality safety
Ongoing
Figure 1.20. End of cycle (EOC) axial burn-up shapes of a fuel assembly at EOC of three consecutive cycles [12]

"Burn-up credit will play a major role in future licensing evaluations for spent fuel storage, transportation and dissolution." –Raap, B., Nomura, Y. and Sartori, E., 2001. Overview of the burnup credit activities at OECD/NEA/NSC.

Introduction

Criticality safety must be guaranteed based on reliable methods in the fuel manufacture, storage, transportation and reprocessing and disposition. However, it is specifically difficult in the case of spent nuclear fuels to estimate the reactivity of spent fuels due to large uncertainties. Limited quantification of spent fuels elemental composition and spatial distribution exists fuels, even if structural/elemental information of fresh fuels and operation history are available. Therefore, to avoid criticality accidents under any considerable conditions, relatively large safety margins are required, knowing that they have significant conservatisms that impose enormous economic burden on  stakeholders.

What is Burn-up Credit?

Burn-up credit is a safety approach that accounts for the reduction in the reactivity of configurations with spent nuclear fuel due to the change in their composition after irradiation. Criticality is the state of a nuclear reactor when there is a self-sustaining chain reaction of fissionable material.

The physics behind burn-up credit

The reactivity of nuclear reactor fuels typically decreases as the fuel burnup proceeds.  Essentially, the decrease in reactivity comes from a reduction in concentration of fissile nuclides and an increase in concentration of fission products that absorb neutrons. Burn-up credit, which is currently of wide interest in the field of nuclear criticality safety research, generally involves taking into account this reactivity decrease for criticality safety assessments and control of spent fuel by crediting burn up of fuel.

NEA work on burn-up credit

To provide information of more accurate safety analysis, Expert Group on Burn-up Credit Criticality Safety (EGBUC) was formed in 1991 and published several benchmark reports. The NEA's activities had examined burn-up credit as applied to criticality safety in the transportation, storage and treatment of spent fuel for a wide range of fuel types and reactors, including UOX and MOX fuels for PWR, BWR and VVER.

Benchmarks on burn-up credit
Benchmark Application Description Status
I-A PWR UOX Multiplication factor, spectra and reaction rates calculations for an infinite PWR fuel rod lattice with varying compositions (different enrichments, burnups, cooling-times, presence or absence of actinides -major and minor- and of fission products - major and minor-

Report published in June 1996

I-B PWR UOX Depletion calculations for a simple infinite PWR pin-cell lattice. Report published in January 1994  
II-A PWR UOX Multiplication factor calculations of an infinite array of PWR fuel with finite axial height. The aim being to study the effect of axial burn-up profile on criticality calculations of PWR fuel storage. Report published in February 1996  
II-B PWR UOX Multiplication factor and spatial fission distribution calculations of a realistic PWR spent fuel transport cask including accidental situations. The aim being to further study the effect of axial burn-up profile on criticality calculations. Report published in May 1998  
II-C PWR UOX Multiplication factor and fission distribution calculations of a realistic PWR fuel transport cask. The aim being to study the sensitivity to the axial burnup shape. Report published in September 2008  
II-D PWR UOX Multiplication factor and fission distribution calculations of a realistic PWR fuel transport cask. The aim being to study control rods effects on spent fuel composition. Report published in December 2006  
II-E PWR UOX Study on the impact of changes in the isotopic inventory due to control rod insertions in PWR UO2 fuel assemblies during irradiation on the end effect Report published in June 2015  
III-A BWR UOX Criticality calculations of an infinite array of BWR spent fuel assemblies with emphasis on axial burnup and void profiles. Report published in September 2000  
III-B BWR UOX Depletion calculations of an array of BWR fuel. Report published in February 2002  
III-C BWR UOX Compositions of Spent Fuel Assembly for BUC and Criticality control of damaged fuel. Report published in March 2016  
IV-A PWR MOX Reactivity Prediction Calculations for Infinite Arrays of PWR MOX Fuel Pin Cells Report published in May 2003  
IV-B PWR MOX Inventory MOX Fuel Depletion Calculations Report published in May 2003  
VI PWR UOX Burn-up profile in a VVER-440 assembly Analysis of results ongoing
VII PWR UOX Study of spent fuel compositions for long-term disposal Report Published February 2012  

Bibliography

File name/title

  • BUC-DM2005
    Bibliography on Burnup Credit compiled by D.Mennerdahl (up to 2005)
  • BUC-ORNL
    Bibliography of BUC related publications compiled and maintained by ORNL (1972 to 2010)
  • BUC-AER
    Bibliography of Burnup credit in Atomic Energy Research (AER) conferences (1997 - 2007)
  • BUC-French
    French Bibliography on BUC compiled by L. Jutier (after 2005)
Publications and reports
5
results